Welcome to Tamarack Pizza
Tamarack Pizza is a charming spot in Portage, Wisconsin, transformed from a railroad train car into a cozy haven for pizza lovers. Known for its friendly atmosphere and flavorful dishes, this Italian pizzeria offers an array of delicious pizzas and sandwiches that cater to various dietary needs. Patrons rave about the warm, welcoming service and the high-quality ingredients, with standout items like the Tamarack Supreme and homemade chili. With outdoor seating, full bar options, and a laid-back vibe, Tamarack Pizza is ideal for families and groups seeking a delightful dining experience. Come for the pizza, stay for the ambiance!
Tamarack Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
We ordered complicated pizzas with various substitutions to meet our family's dietary needs and preferences and I was pleasantly surprised that everything was as we ordered AND they were both delicious pizzas. The crust had a nice texture and taste too. We did get the pizzas to go this time but everyone was warm and welcoming inside. They are cash only. My daughter just moved to Portage and we will definitely be going back to Tamarack when we are visiting.
We dropped into Tamarack Pizza yesterday in Portage, Wisconsin, and were met with the warmest throw back ambience encounter. The mellow yellow lit brown hued background drenched with charm, highlighted early advertising beer mirrors of all sizes across the walls. The elongated walls were quite reminiscent of Chicago's Geno's East style paneled wooden walls just waiting to be tagged by customers declaring their presence in this actual railroad train car, now turned cozy pizza place on Wisconsin Street. We were greeted by a very friendly pony tailed waitress who served our appetizer request consisting of a bowl of chili. We were anxious to receive the Chef's homemade Chili response. All the goodness was there including, a high quality ground beef, as well as, all the added veggies and spices for a hearty chili dish. Next, by mutual agreement a shrimp, anchovies, onion, green olives, and green pepper, on a thin large pizza was ordered. The request was returned with reasonable speed and presentation. Our waitress had the biggest smile on her face; assuring and knowing what our responses would be once we tasted this pie! We went in on it, and in no time there were only two pieces left! It was a small piece of totally good and seriously rad eats in a quaint small town, not so far north of Chicago! What a delightful Friday afternoon spent at Tamarack Pizza, in Portage, Wisconsin.
Pizza was fantastic, the crust was t soggy, cheese was delicious. As a vegetarian, I was disappointed to find that the broccoli bites had bacon in them - after I had taken a bite. Beer selection was minimal, but enjoyed the spotted cow beer. Our server was slightly irritated with our group, but I think we won her over. Overall our group had a great night eating pizza and drinking beer.
Good service. We ordered a pizza with lightly sautéed mushrooms and black olives. Super-thin crust. Sauce was my favorite--loved the oregano. Not the most comfortable seating, but it probably keeps people moving along. Fair pricing. Clean bathrooms. Steep steps going up into the restaurant/bar.
Took a break from fishing and stopped in this place for a pie and some beer, with my son. The pizza was very good, obviously the beer was great. We were just about done, when Hank burst in the front door. He instantly announced "I have to crap and it is going to smell!" Everyone turned and looked at him. A couple of locals got up from the bar. They were older but tough. "Not in my bar Hank!" One yelled at him, then the 2 quickly tacked Hank to the floor, Hank was no match for them. They dragged his ass back out the front door. "Be careful on you way out, he crapped himself and passed out." I recommend Tamarack Pizza, I do not recommend Hank.
Location
-
412 E Wisconsin St, Portage, WI 53901 Hotline: (608) 742-6424
Welcome to Tamarack Pizza: Your Destination for Authentic Italian Comfort Food
Nestled at 412 E Wisconsin St, Portage, WI 53901, Tamarack Pizza stands out as a vibrant hub for pizza lovers and casual diners alike. This charming establishment boasts a welcoming atmosphere, a full bar, and an impressive array of dining utilities including delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating, catering to diverse tastes and preferences.
Ambiance and Experience
Stepping into Tamarack Pizza, you'll be greeted by a nostalgic charm that evokes memories of classic pizza joints. The mellow yellow-lit ambiance and rustic wooden panels add character, making it the perfect place for family gatherings or a casual night out with friends. Patrons rave about the warm service, noting that the wait staff is friendly and accommodating, ensuring a delightful dining experience.
Culinary Offerings
The menu at Tamarack Pizza is a tapestry of delicious Italian offerings, focusing primarily on their renowned pizzas. With options ranging from classic pepperoni to unique combinations like shrimp and anchovies, there’s something to satisfy every palate. Many customers have praised the crust for its perfect texture and flavor, an essential component that makes each pie truly memorable. Families can also find a variety of sandwiches, such as the hearty Chicken Cordon Bleu or flavorful Reuben, ensuring there's more than just pizza to savor.
- Top Favorites: Enjoy delightful toppings including banana peppers, mushrooms, olives, and garlic bread, or customize your order to meet dietary needs, as noted by satisfied patrons.
- Hearty Sandwiches: The menu features delightful options such as Grilled Chicken Breast and Gyro, adding variety to your meal.
- Family-Friendly: With a casual dress code and a welcoming atmosphere, Tamarack is perfect for children and groups, making it the ideal spot for family dinners.
Community Feel and Customer Feedback
Tamarack Pizza isn’t just about food; it’s about community. Many reviews highlight the friendly vibe, where customers often engage in lively conversations that echo the ethos of a local pizzeria. Whether it’s a thoughtful waitress or locals sharing laughter, the establishment captures the essence of small-town hospitality. Regulars recount their unforgettable experiences, from sampling the chef's homemade chili to cheering for their favorite sports on TV coupled with a cool beer selection.
Though there might be occasional hiccups—like limited beer options or minor service slips—what stands out is the willingness of the staff to make things right, and patrons often leave with smiles and full bellies. Tamarack Pizza proves itself as a beloved spot in Portage, where you can always expect comforting flavors and a welcoming atmosphere.
In Conclusion
If you're in the Portage area and craving a slice of life with a side of charm, Tamarack Pizza welcomes you with open arms. With a fantastic selection of pizzas, sandwiches, and a cozy ambiance, it’s no surprise that this local gem continues to win the hearts of many. Don’t forget to reserve your spot or give them a call at (608) 742-6424 for a potential pizza adventure—it’s a culinary journey you don’t want to miss!
